Da The New York Times del 04/02/2005
Originale su http://www.nytimes.com/2005/02/04/international/04food.html?ei=5094&am...

Inquiry on Food-for-Oil Plan Cites U.N. Diplomat for Conflict

di Warren Hoge, Judith Miller

An interim report by a commission investigating the United Nations oil-for-food program in Iraq said the former head of the program had violated the United Nations Charter by helping a company owned by a friend to obtain valuable contracts to sell Iraqi oil.

The conduct of Benon V. Sevan, a Cypriot official who ran the program from 1997 until its demise in 2003, was a "grave and continuing conflict of interest" and had "seriously undermined the integrity of the United Nations," the report concludes.

The 219-page report, issued yesterday by the Independent Inquiry Committee, the United Nations-appointed panel headed by Paul A. Volcker, the former Federal Reserve chairman, depicts what was the United Nations' largest relief effort as riddled with political favoritism and mismanagement.

The $64 billion program, under which Iraqi oil revenues were used to buy relief goods for Iraqis, is also being investigated by five Congressional committees and a federal prosecutor in New York.

The report also says officials violated United Nations competitive bidding rules in hiring contractors for the program. It says important parts of the program were not audited, allowing evidence that Saddam Hussein was demanding and receiving kickbacks from companies selling his oil to go undetected.

A senior United Nations official announced yesterday that Secretary General Kofi Annan would try to discipline Mr. Sevan, who retired last year, and another senior official, Joseph Stephanides, who oversaw the selection of the program's major contractors.

The report does not say that Mr. Sevan, or other officials it criticizes, benefited personally from their actions.

But it discloses that Mr. Sevan received $160,000 in cash between 1999 to 2003 from an aunt in Cyprus, a retired government photographer who has since died. Mr. Volcker did not tie that money to his efforts on behalf of his friend's company, but the report says that the aunt's way of life did not suggest that she was wealthy and that the panel was continuing to investigate "the full scope and extent of benefits received by Mr. Sevan."

It also discloses that the Swiss-based company that Mr. Sevan helped, Africa Middle East Petroleum, made a $1.5 million profit by selling the oil allocations that Mr. Sevan had repeatedly solicited on its behalf from senior Iraqi officials. The report accuses the company of paying an illegal surcharge of $160,088 to Iraq in 2001.

In a statement yesterday, Eric L. Lewis, a lawyer for Mr. Sevan, denied his client had acted improperly. He said Mr. Sevan had no interest in any oil company and had never "accepted anything from anyone." The statement said he had always acted "in the best interests" of the oil-for-food program and the United Nations.

Mr. Lewis accused the panel of trying to "scapegoat" Mr. Sevan for "mentioning a company to the Iraqis as part of his role in advancing the process of trading oil for food."

"Mr. Sevan never took a penny," Mr. Lewis said, accusing the commission of succumbing to "massive political pressure."

Describing Mr. Sevan as "proud" of his 40-year service to the United Nations in some of the world's most dangerous places, the statement said that Mr. Sevan had fully disclosed the income he had received from his aunt.

The report accuses Mr. Sevan of not having been "forthcoming" with the committee about his relationship with the oil company, AMEP, or its owner, Fakhry Abdelnour, a distant relative of Boutros Boutros-Ghali, the former United Nations secretary general, whom the report criticizes separately for his role in selecting the program's main banker.

Reached by telephone in Paris, Mr. Boutros-Ghali said he had done nothing improper, calling Mr. Volcker's investigators "ignorant" of the United Nations system and their allegations about his conduct "silly."

Mr. Volcker said yesterday that the panel was continuing to investigate Mr. Sevan and his connections to Mr. Abdelnour, his company and other friends and associates.

Efforts to locate Mr. Abdelnour for comment yesterday were not successful. A call placed to his office in Geneva was not answered yesterday evening.

Mr. Stephanides, who oversaw contractor selection, did not return messages left on his office phone Wednesday night and yesterday morning.

Mark Malloch Brown, Mr. Annan's new chief of staff, said Mr. Stephanides could pay a high price as a result of disciplinary action up to and including dismissal, but he acknowledged that there was little the United Nations could do about Mr. Sevan, since he had retired. He said Mr. Annan would immediately lift the diplomatic immunity of any United Nations official charged with criminal conduct.

Mr. Volcker said, "This is a painful episode for everyone in the U.N."

This interim report defers judgment on fundamental issues of responsibility for corruption in the oil-for-food program, saying its investigations are continuing. Mr. Volcker and the two other commissioners - Richard Goldstone, a South African judge, and Mark Pieth, a Swiss financial expert - specifically deferred comment, for example, on allegations that the secretary general had a conflict of interest because his son Kojo had worked for Cotecna Inspection, a Swiss-based company hired to inspect the aid bought by Iraq.

Mr. Annan, who became secretary general in 1997, has previously said he had no role in selecting contractors.

Mr. Volcker said he hoped to issue his final report this summer.

The interim report, however, criticizes the way in which United Nations officials selected all three of the program's major contractors: Banque Nationale de Paris, a French bank that the panel said was not even on the United Nations' initial "long list" of the most technically qualified banks for the program; Saybolt Eastern Hemisphere BV, a Dutch oil inspection company that Mr. Stephanides was said to have promoted; and Lloyd's Register Inspection Ltd. of Britain, which the report said was chosen partly to balance lucrative contracts geographically among member nations.

The panel's investigators found "convincing and uncontested evidence" that the selection process had been "tainted" by irregularities in the case of all three contractors. The report does not accuse the contractors of acting illegally.

Both the report and Mr. Volcker emphasized that the major source of Mr. Hussein's illicit money was not kickbacks from the oil-for-food program but the estimated $8 billion in illegal oil sales to Jordan, Turkey and Syria that occurred even before the program was created. Mr. Volcker said that those sales were known to Security Council members, including the United States, and that Washington had specifically waived American laws barring such sales.

The report reserves its harshest criticism for Mr. Sevan, whose contacts with Iraqi officials on behalf of Mr. Abdelnour and his company AMEP, it details. The report states that Mr. Sevan first asked senior Iraqi officials for an allocation of oil "to help a friend" who was from Egypt in mid-1998, soon after the Security Council permitted Iraq to use up to $300 million of oil revenues to purchase spare parts for renovations. It was "highly unlikely," the report notes, "that Iraq would sell oil to a company such as AMEP unless sponsored by a beneficiary that Iraqi officials wished to favor."

Citing several Iraqi documents, the report concludes that Iraqi officials gave the allocations to AMEP at Mr. Sevan's requests hoping that this would "ensure a good relationship with him" and would help them obtain Mr. Sevan's assistance in lifting holds on spare part sales that Security Council members had placed on them.

The former Iraqi oil minister, Muhammad Rashid, specifically told the panel's investigators that the Iraqi government had allocated oil to Mr. Sevan "because 'he was a man of influence,' " the report states.

After Mr. Sevan turned out not to be "as helpful as hoped," it continues, the allocations for AMEP were reduced. "Neither Mr. Sevan nor Mr. Abdelnour was pleased with the reduction in the oil allocation," the report says. Mr. Sevan spoke to Mr. Rashid about it at an OPEC conference in Vienna in March 1999.

In the next phase of the program, AMEP's allocation was restored within five days after Mr. Sevan traveled to Iraqi to meet with Mr. Rashid again in the summer of 1999 to "discuss an expansion of the oil spare parts program."

The report says Mr. Sevan "denies that he asked for oil allocations or recommended any company to Iraqi officials for purchasing oil."

"But these claims are contradicted by the firsthand accounts of Iraqi officials involved," as well as by Iraqi oil company documents that list both Mr. Sevan and AMEP as recipients, "often following occasions when Mr. Sevan met with Oil Minister Rashid," the report states.

The report says Mr. Abdelnour said Mr. Sevan did not assist him in obtaining the allocations from Iraq.

It says Mr. Sevan initially told investigators he had met Mr. Abdelnour only briefly at the OPEC Vienna conference in 1999. But in later interviews he "admitted that he had passed at least one inquiry from Mr. Abdelnour to the Iraqi oil minister."

The report says that after being confronted with United Nations telephone records showing calls between himself and Mr. Abdelnour, Mr. Sevan acknowledged that the two men had "developed an acquaintanceship" lasting "over several years." It quotes Mr. Sevan as telling investigators: "I came to like the guy. He is an interesting character you know, he's been around the world."

At the United Nations, Mr. Malloch Brown said the secretary general was shocked at the report's findings about Mr. Sevan in particular.

"The secretary general is shocked by what the report has to say about Mr. Sevan, terribly dismayed that a colleague of so many years' standing is accused of breaching the U.N. code of conduct and staff rules in the ways he did, and he very much doubts that there can be any extenuating circumstances for the behavior which appears proven in the report," Mr. Malloch Brown said.

The mood toward Mr. Sevan, a longtime friend and confidant of Mr. Annan's, appeared unforgiving.

Mr. Malloch Brown said: "Let me be clear that while Benon Sevan is a very dear friend of many of us - I've worked with him for years - when you put together three international investigators, $34 million worth of investigations, 65 investigators, you don't then set yourselves up as a court of appeal over the results of that investigation." Any further investigation, he said, would be in "a judicial process."

Reaction to the report from Congressional investigators was mostly supportive of Mr. Volcker's work.

Representative Henry J. Hyde, the Illinois Republican who is the chairman of the House International Relations Committee, said in a statement that the report painted a picture of "mismanagement, neglect and political manipulation that resulted in significant corruption of the oil-for-food program."

"I am reluctant to conclude that the U.N. is damaged beyond repair," he said, "but these revelations certainly point in this direction."

A similar, but even harsher reaction came from Senator Norm Coleman, a Minnesota Republican and chairman of the Senate Permanent Committee on Investigations, who called on Mr. Annan to lift Mr. Sevan's diplomatic immunity immediately. "The report shows that he repeatedly lied to investigators, has misled the inquiry about the source of $160,000 in cash deposits and unethically steered oil-for-food contracts to close associates and lied about those relationships to authorities," he said.

Sullo stesso argomento

Articoli in archivio

Anche gli ex ministri degli Interni Joxe e Pasqua accusati con altri politici francesi e russi di aver preso tangenti sul petrolio
Francia, tutti gli amici di Saddam scandalo per la lista della Cia
Protesta del Quay d´Orsay per il "metodo seguito"
di Giampiero Martinotti su La Repubblica del 08/10/2004
 
Cos'� ArchivioStampa?
Una finestra sul mondo della cultura, della politica, dell'economia e della scienza. Ogni giorno, una selezione di articoli comparsi sulla stampa italiana e internazionale. [Leggi]
Rassegna personale
Attualmente non hai selezionato directory degli articoli da incrociare.
Sponsor
Contenuti
Notizie dal mondo
Notizie dal mondo
Community
• Forum
Elenco degli utenti

Sono nuovo... registratemi!
Ho dimenticato la password
• Sono già registrato:
User ID

Password
Network
Newsletter

iscriviti cancella
Suggerisci questo sito

Attenzione
I documenti raccolti in questo sito non rappresentano il parere degli autori che si sono limitatati a raccoglierli come strumento di studio e analisi.
Comune di Roma

Questo progetto imprenditoriale ha ottenuto il sostegno del Comune di Roma nell'ambito delle azioni di sviluppo e recupero delle periferie

by Mondo a Colori Media Network s.r.l. 2006-2024
Valid XHTML 1.0, CSS 2.0